Tasting Menus in Northeast Florida: The Perfect Date Night Escape

tasting menus
Rue Saint-Marc is one of many date night-worthy restaurants in Jacksonville that offer multi-course tasting menus. Photo courtesy of Rue Saint-Marc/Facebook.

If you’re anything like me, juggling kids, work, and the daily chaos of family life, the idea of a quiet, indulgent evening feels almost mythical. Whether you’re looking to impress your special someone or treat yourselves to a well-deserved night out, Northeast Florida has no shortage of tasting menus designed to sweep you off your feet.

READ: Best Date Night Restaurants in Jacksonville

From intimate, chef-driven experiences to farm-to-table creations, these restaurants serve up more than just dinner — they offer a dining escape. So, book the sitter, throw on something other than yoga pants, and get ready to savor every bite of your well-earned night away.

Mesa Restaurant (Avondale)

Mesa sets the stage for romance with its intimate atmosphere and globally inspired flavors. Their five-course tasting menu ($65 per person) is a love letter to modern cuisine, with highlights like Truffle Puri and Mesa Chicken Curry. Pair it with the optional three-course wine pairing ($35) for an unforgettable evening.

Why it’s perfect: Low lighting, bold flavors, and just enough elegance to make you feel like grownups again.

Congaree and Penn (Northside)

For a date night with a side of rustic charm, Congaree and Penn’s six-course tasting menu is served among picturesque grapevines. Each dish is crafted with seasonal, locally sourced ingredients, and optional wine pairings elevate the experience.

Why it’s perfect: The farm-to-table concept feels earthy and romantic, and the serene surroundings are a breath of fresh air — literally.

Matthew’s in San Marco offers six- or eight-course tasting menus.

Matthew’s Restaurant (San Marco)

Matthew’s is a tried-and-true classic for special occasions. Their Chef’s Adventure Tasting Menu offers six or eight courses ($115–$150) that are as stunning as they are delicious. Add the optional wine pairing ($50) for a meal that feels like a celebration of love and flavor.

Why it’s perfect: It’s sophisticated, luxurious, and the kind of place where you’ll probably hold hands across the table.

Rue Saint-Marc (San Marco)

This French-inspired gem is ideal for couples looking for a cozy, chic vibe. Rue Saint Marc’s tasting menus are crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients and presented with artistic flair.

Why it’s perfect: French food, candlelit ambiance, and no kids asking for ketchup — it’s basically the formula for romance.

Cuisine 76 and Bar (5 Points)

Cuisine 76 offers a blend of international and local flavors, with a tasting menu designed to showcase seasonal ingredients. The presentation is as stunning as the dishes themselves, making every course a mini work of art.

Why it’s perfect: The chic yet welcoming vibe makes it ideal for couples who want sophistication without pretension.

City Grill and Raw Bar (San Marco)

The seafood-centric spot known as City Grill occasionally features tasting events with fresh, innovative dishes paired perfectly with wines or cocktails. It’s a laid-back yet indulgent choice for couples who love seafood.

Why it’s perfect: Fresh flavors, a stylish setting, and the option to toast with expertly crafted cocktails.

tasting menus
13 Gypsies in Riverside offers an eclectic tasting menu with a Spanish focus.

13 Gypsies (Riverside)

13 Gypsies is a cozy, family-owned spot that specializes in artisan small plates inspired by Mediterranean and Spanish flavors. Chef Kevan’s Tasting Menu offers a curated selection of their best dishes, showcasing everything from house-made charcuterie to creative takes on classic tapas.

Why it’s perfect: The intimate atmosphere and bold, shareable flavors make it feel like a culinary journey through Europe. Ideal for adventurous couples who love variety.

Norikase (Southside)

For adventurous foodies, Norikase offers a 17-course Omakase Chef’s Tasting Menu that’s equal parts art and cuisine. Each bite is a masterpiece, blending Japanese traditions with modern creativity.

Why it’s perfect: It’s intimate, unique, and a true shared experience — one you’ll still be talking about by dessert.

Llama Restaurant (St. Augustine)

If you’re in the mood for something out of the ordinary, Llama brings the vibrant flavors of Peru to your plate. Their tasting menu is a bold, innovative celebration of Peruvian cuisine.

Why it’s perfect: Exotic flavors meet intimate dining — this is for couples who love to explore the world together, one bite at a time.

tasting menus
Chef Zachary Drawdy creates a delectable tasting menu for residents at The Plantation of Ponte Vedra Beach.

Pro Tips for Enjoying a Tasting Menu

To make the most of your indulgent tasting menu experience, keep these tips in mind:

Trust the pairings. Many tasting menus offer optional wine pairings for each course, usually curated by an in-house sommelier. These pairings are carefully designed to enhance the flavors of each dish, and they’re often more affordable than you’d think. If you enjoy wine, this is a must-try addition!

Communicate dietary restrictions in advance. If you have allergies or specific dietary preferences, let the restaurant know when you make your reservation. Most chefs are happy to accommodate, but they’ll need advance notice to prepare something equally special for you.

Be open-minded. Tasting menus are all about discovery. Even if something on the menu isn’t your usual go-to, trust the chef’s expertise and let them surprise you. Many dishes are crafted to showcase the season’s best ingredients or the chef’s unique creativity — you might just discover a new favorite!

tasting menus
Don’t forget to take time to enjoy one another’s company!

Pace yourself. Tasting menus are a marathon, not a sprint. Enjoy each course slowly, taking time to savor the flavors and textures. Remember, this is as much about the experience as the food itself.

Ask questions. Don’t be shy about asking your server or sommelier about the dishes or pairings. They’re there to guide you through the experience and often have fascinating insights into the ingredients, techniques, and inspiration behind each course.

Make a night of it. Tasting menus are meant to be savored, so plan your evening accordingly. Arrive early, dress up a bit, and soak in the ambiance — it’s all part of the magic.

Ready to indulge? Make your reservation soon — these spots fill up fast. And don’t forget to snap a pic for the ’gram (because if it’s not on social media, did it even happen?). Here’s to love, laughter, and a few courses you don’t have to share with the kids.

Prices are subject to change.

Hannah Windsor
Hannah Windsor is not just a seasoned real estate professional; she’s a devoted mother and an active member of the Jacksonville community. With roots in Kent, England, and a childhood spent in Madrid, Spain, Hannah brings a unique global perspective to her life and work. Fluent in English and Castilian Spanish, she effortlessly connects with people from all walks of life, making her a valued member of the diverse Jacksonville community. Now settled in Northeast Florida, Hannah’s passion for helping families find their place is matched only by her commitment to supporting local causes. As a board member of The Jericho School of Autism and a dedicated advocate for autism awareness, she draws from her personal experiences as the mother of an autistic child to make a meaningful impact. Hannah enjoys sharing her insights on balancing motherhood with a fulfilling career, as well as offering tips for creating a nurturing home environment. Whether she’s contributing to Jacksonville Mom, engaging with the Rotary Club of San Marco, where she serves as Public Relations Chair, or simply enjoying her garden with a cup of tea in hand, Hannah is always focused on building strong, supportive communities.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here